The NYU Intesa Sanpaolo Center for Transnational Litigation, Arbitration, and Commercial Law is pleased to announce that the scholarship of its Director, Professor Franco Ferrari, the Clarence D. Ashley Professor of Law, was cited by Brazil’s Superior Court of Justice (Superior Tribunal de Justiça, STJ). The STJ is the country’s highest court on federal law, including arbitration law and the New York Convention.
In a unanimous decision of its Third Panel on October 6, 2026 (REsp 2.224.272/SP, reporting Justice Nancy Andrighi), the Court relied on Reconhecimento e execução de sentenças arbitrais estrangeiras(Quartier Latin, 2023), a book co-authored by Professor Ferrari with Professor Friedrich Rosenfeld (and Professor Mariana França Gouveia. Professor Rosenfeld is Global Adjunct Professor of Law at NYU Law in Paris, Visiting Professor at the International Hellenic University in Thessaloniki, and a partner at the arbitration firm Hanefeld. Professor França Gouveia is a Full Professor and former Dean of NOVA School of Law in Lisbon.
Background
The case arose from a share purchase agreement for control of a Brazilian bank. The parties agreed to ICC arbitration seated in New York. They also agreed that Brazilian law would govern both the contract and the arbitral procedure, and that any action to set aside the award would be brought in São Paulo. After the award was rendered, the losing party sought to annul it in the São Paulo courts. The court of appeals dismissed the action. It held that a foreign award can be reviewed in Brazil only through recognition proceedings before the STJ.
The decision
The STJ reversed. As a general rule, only courts at the seat of arbitration may annul an award. The Court found an exception in Article V(1)(e) of the New York Convention. That provision contemplates the setting aside of an award not only in the country where it was made, but also in the country “under the law of which” it was made.
To interpret that phrase, the Court cited Professor Ferrari’s book, together with the UNCITRAL New York Convention Guide and decisions of U.S. and Hong Kong courts. On that basis it held that the phrase refers to the law governing the arbitral procedure (the lex arbitri), not the law governing the merits. Because the parties chose Brazilian procedural law, Brazilian courts have jurisdiction to hear the annulment action. The case now returns to the São Paulo Court of Appeals for a ruling on the merits.
The decision is a significant statement on the role of the lex arbitri in setting aside awards outside the seat.